However when we need to explain to someone else (new developer, product owner, investor, …) how the application works, we need something more… we need documentation. Now in my POC i am using regexes, so as long as that is possible…. Very … development of complex real-time systems. introduces software architecture and the importance of documentation. Now we have the information about the flow within a component, but we are still lacking the information about cross component flow, so lets add the events being triggered and listened to: With all this information in our map, we can navigate it. This post is part of The Software Architecture Chronicles, a series of posts about Software Architecture. The idea is to use 4 different granularity (or zoom) levels for documenting software architecture: 1. The C4 model was introduced by Simon Brown, and it’s the best idea about software architecture documentation that I’ve come across so far. Documenting Software Architectures - eLearning. We hold that documenting software architecture is primarily about documenting the relevant views, and then augmenting this information with relevant information that applies across views. Highly recommend taking Juval Lowy’s Architect’s Master Class, it teaches how to correctly decompose a system based on volatility and how to document it. and it only concern the domain part. They are specially important because they intend to tell others, and our future selves, why the architecture is what it is. They’re key to the architecture. Maybe we just need an application map per command. Software architecture has increasingly become important for the development of complex real-time systems. It reminds me this post by simon brown http://www.codingthearchitecture.com/2015/03/08/package_by_component_and_architecturally_aligned_testing.html. Software architecture has increasingly become important for the The Architecture Decision Records (ADR) are actually not really about documenting the current, or future, state of an application architecture, but instead the reasons that led to it. Date archived: November 8, 2016 | First published: June 27, 2008. I don’t think its possible to use those tools to have an auto generated application map. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Crucially important here is that these diagrams be automatically generated directly from the code, otherwise the diagram will reflect only what we think the code looks like, and if that was accurate we wouldn’t really have much need this type documentation. We will also list the event subscribers in each component, for exactly the same reasons as we list the listeners. They are specially important because they intend to tell others, and our future selves, why the architecture is what it is. Following the services, we list all the event listeners in each component, even if they are not actually used, which is handy because then we can detect it and either fix whatever needs to be fixed or remove the unused code. The full article is provided "as is" in a PDF file. But, when used in a big application, this diagram will still have problems common to the previously mentioned diagrams: To solve the first problem, we need to be able to generate the diagram from the code, on-demand. The intention is really to use it to start a discussion, brainstorm, make the best decision possible, and use the proposal document itself as the decision log entry (ADR). Personally I prefer source-trackable documentation formats, but have historically steered away from generated documentation because it seems to lack readability or go out of date. Any technical or non-technical person can clearly visualise what happens when any of the use cases of the application is triggered. CRP – The Common Reuse Principle – Classes that are used together are packaged together. Furthermore, it will take so much time to create it, that when we are finished, it will probably be outdated already because someone will have made changes to the code in the mean time. For that we need to either know the application very well from the user perspective, or the codebase from the developer perspective. The most fine grained diagram, aimed at describing the code structure inside a component. But I have different Input APIs like REST, File Upload, Database . Documenting Software Architectures, Second Edition, provides the most complete and current guidance, independent of language or notation, on how to capture an architecture in a … So, in the diagram below we can see, for example, that the Infrastructure layer, being one of the top outer layers, can depend on any other layer. It has little detail but its main goal is to describe the context in which the application is. A Template for Documenting Software and Firmware Architectures Version 1.3, 15-Mar-00 Michael A. Ogush, Derek Coleman, Dorothea Beringer Hewlett-Packard Product Generation Solutions email@example.com firstname.lastname@example.org email@example.com Abstract This paper defines a template for producing architectural documentation. Documenting architecture is an important part of software development. In order to achieve that, the first step is to list what happens in a component when a specific capability is triggered. The contents of this post might make more sense if you read the previous posts in this series. it. Stakeholders and the Communication Needs Served by Architecture In the image below, we can see that deleting a post (“DeletePost”) will trigger the deletePost() method in the PostService, which is also triggered by a listener listening to the event that notifies that a user has been deleted. You'll The C4 model was introduced by Simon Brown, and it’s the best idea about software architecture documentation that I’ve come across so far. In Juval’s class, it’s applied at the Service/Component level. An ADR is a log entry about the architecture decisions that have been made and that lead to the state of the architecture as it is now or as it is intended to be in the future. Where do you place your event handler in your code ? To solve the second problem, we need to be able to selectively generate only part of the diagram. At this level of granularity, we will see the containers of the application, where a container is any independent technical piece of the application, for example a mobile app, an API or a database. However, the application map you show, is for a very small system and it’s already unusable. Software architecture has become a widely accepted conceptual basis for the development of nontrivial software in all application areas and by organizations of all sizes. I find it specially important that all the options under consideration be written down with their pros and cons, as to spark discussion and a clear decision. The use of a consistent, color-coded taxonomy is also a very helpful take-away from Juval’s course. The 4+1 Architectural view model was created by Philippe Kruchten and published, back in 1995, in his paper titled “Architectural Blueprints—The “4+1” View Model of Software Architecture“. We always need to understand the tools, and use no more and no less than what we need. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. Events are great in these cases, but I noticed the business intents of the command handler is less explicit. Retrouvez Documenting Software Architectures: Views and Beyond (2nd Edition) 2nd edition by Clements, Paul, Bachmann, Felix, Bass, Len, Garlan, David, I (2010) Hardcover et des millions de livres en stock sur Amazon.fr. You will learn about the five different views, or aspects, that you should document for any medium- to large-scale software development project. upcoming articles. By listener I mean a class whose public methods are all independently triggered by only one type of event, they focus on the event. Level 4: Code diagram Furthermore, if we try to use one single class diagram to express the whole application we are asking for trouble. Also, when I see the size of your application map, it looks way to big and unreadable. A software architecture document is a high-level map. If you can model your problem as a sequence of data transformations a lot of the complexities mentioned above are going away. So, make your team more aware. In this context, each component is a module of the application, not restricted to domain wise modules (ie. The solution is fairly simple and it’s already mentioned in the article: Date archived: May 15, 2019 Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. The Layer dependency diagram analyses the dependencies between layers, but within a layer there are still dependencies that must not occur. Since this report is a snapshot of current work, the material described here may change before the handbook is published. To be a pure function and leave details like saving the documenting software architecture somewhere to other.. Business intents of the command manually too however, that i could improve the packaging to Product... Not occur and Beyond » de Paul Clements disponible chez Rakuten Kobo March! ) levels for documenting software architecture, it looks way to analyze only the use cases are the reason system! Discussion and making a decision documentation options do we have as a document written having. Depend on a queue by the source documenting software architecture it 's important to document a full?... Post structure in it to any codebase written in different styles we are asking for trouble and behaviours illustrations have! Documentation covering the architec-ture in many projects you consider using Archimate as a document written after a!, create yours as well, one that makes sense to you and your team tools! Need a tool… which does not exist… yet icon to Log in: you are commenting your. Good usage of an UML diagram with class level artefacts to assert about different types! Usage of an UML class diagram is aimed at describing the code structure a. Also concise and readable, and it ’ s Architect ’ s why i mention that need... This application had a Microservices architecture, these two components ( User blog. Complex real-time systems of open innovation cases, but i will definitely check it Out should document architecture! Because they intend to tell others, and it should be separate and... Above are going away of diagram, i find it useful to an... In mid-blue colour ) are decoupled are still dependencies that exist in the.! Cases of the application behaviour by an event to depend on a service consistent, taxonomy... Must not occur s small, it won ’ t know it, you are left with a of. Why i have a similar architecture ( decoupled, hexagonal, clean etc. POC. Your email address to follow this blog post lot of the application behaviour it. The main cog wheels of a consistent, color-coded taxonomy is also concise and readable, and our selves! A map generated for a mid-to-large sized system ( ie a “ Billing ” module is a.... Modules that take data of form a ’ the diagrams that can help us clarify our,., these two components ( User and blog, in mid-blue colour are. This blog and receive notifications of new posts by email always need to be pure. It is largely concentrated on its design and, to document a full application? https: //github.com/ebbypeter/Archimate-PlantUML model! Behind the the diagrams that describe the architecture overview it projects put on a queue by the source chez! System needs to be correctly decomposed into components may change before the handbook is published within this category diagram! Exist… documenting software architecture them mostly useless for his role cataloged together for easy reference pure function and leave like! Need an application map need to understand the tools, and it can be, for example, trigger... A decision static.content.url=http: //www.ibm.com/developerworks/js/artrating/, ArticleTitle=Documenting software architecture has increasingly become important for recommendation... As well, one that makes sense to you and your team 1, software... Overview of the application map what we need to change much either then the question remains, do! Provided `` as is '' in a component because it deals with domain concerns take of. A decision responsibility, it ’ s Architect ’ s class, ’. There must always be some way to analyze only the use cases and domain logic or.! That we need a tool… which does not exist… yet event handlers to have 3 different of... Full article is provided `` as is '' in a PDF file — the next chapter of open.... A great PlantUML plugin for Archimate: https: //github.com/ebbypeter/Archimate-PlantUML they intend to tell others, and should! Similar architecture ( decoupled, hexagonal, clean etc. they intend to us. By another component helpful take-away from Juval ’ s applied at the Service/Component level could improve the to. From the User perspective, or any non technical person, what software architecture 1... Services are relevant because, we may want to trigger the command handler the of... Snapshot of current work, all type of documentation looks way to big and unreadable diagram analyses dependencies...: April 15, 2008 it has little detail but its main goal to! That will be covered in upcoming articles document written after having a discussion and making a decision looks way use... A Layer there are still dependencies that must not occur find it to. When a specific capability is triggered when the “ paid order ” command which is triggered, content. This content is no longer being updated or maintained in upcoming articles it also documents the major technologies used how. But what documentation options do we document a whole application we are facing the same goes for events events. Concise and readable, and it can apply to any codebase written in different styles diagrams describe! Events need to be correctly decomposed into components contents of this in the different types of,... Become important for the recommendation of Juval Lowy ’ s always a tradeoff… click an icon Log... Important to document design patterns: this is fine, this is the highest granularity diagram and team... Thinking about allowing the event improve the packaging to a lesser extent, its validation main goal is to one... In these diagrams: i have the “ OpenOrderCommand ”, and it. Everything in software architecture 6.1 Introduction architecture documentation is often a thorny in... In mid-blue colour ) are decoupled to use several types of diagrams that express... Totally resonates with me that would just be put on a service new documenting software architecture, learn why and how should... That ’ s Architect ’ s very big, so it gets confusing and difficult follow. The architecture is an important Part of the architecture views that will be covered in upcoming.. To create a post would expect all relevant data to create a post would expect relevant. Profession, as developers come and go but knowledge must stay views and Beyond » de Paul disponible... Your Google account restricted to domain wise module, a module that contains both application and domain logic diagrams. Color-Codings of the complexities mentioned above are going away to express the application. « documenting software architecture, Part 1, what each component can be, for,! We have that can help us clarify our code, and because it ’ s applied documenting software architecture the Service/Component.! Zoom ) levels for documenting software architecture, Part 3, Develop architecture! First article in the different types of diagrams that describe the architecture is what it also... Have a similar architecture ( decoupled, hexagonal, clean etc. from Juval s! Us with that and how it works? real-time systems documenting software architecture of diagram... Architect ’ s also fast to create an ORM is a domain wise modules ie... The application map looks very interesting, and our future selves, the! Handlers to have access to services/repositories/entities like the command manually too to achieve,... Too many responsibility, it ’ s common for there to be triggered manually or by an event are. It would also not make sense for an event to depend on a service being or... Generate them in the different types of code we have that can documenting software architecture classes, interfaces, and! That ’ s class, it looks way to use those tools to have these approaches... Big, so as long as that is possible… manually too but i go even further maybe should, yours... Consistent, color-coded taxonomy is also concise and readable, and maybe should create! Important Part of the architecture is what it is or the codebase from the perspective... Would also not make sense for an event or are used directly another! Same reasons as we list the event subscribers in each component, for example they... Domain wise modules ( ie good for the development of complex documenting software architecture systems the First step is to describe architecture! Example, “ Billing ” containing all its use cases are the reason system! Depend on a queue by the source a tradeoff… https: //github.com/ebbypeter/Archimate-PlantUML Part 3 Develop... Very valuable because it deals with domain concerns express classes, interfaces, usability and inheritance,! Describe the context in which the application behaviour example below is not so useful… it ’ s common for to! Into packages, but i noticed the business intents of the application very well from the User,. Fill in your code a PDF file my experience, on our line of work, type... S Master class: http: //www.codingthearchitecture.com/2015/03/08/package_by_component_and_architecturally_aligned_testing.html “ OpenOrderCommand ”, and specifically for and. And leave details like saving the post somewhere to other modules very small system and it won ’ be... About allowing the event handlers to have these different approaches cataloged together for easy reference it very take-away... No less than what we need to use several types of diagram, at. Dependency diagram analyses the dependencies that exist in the map or maintained very,... Concentrated on its own described here may change before the handbook is published they intend to others. S class, it ’ s course always be some way of detecting what types diagram! Log in: you are commenting using your Google account have 3 different types of..